| PSAC Honors |
|
| Athlete of the Year |
| 1996-Jim Gerner |
| 1998-Ryan Vogelsong |
| 1999-John Rozich |
| 2000-Steve Fitch |
| 2001-Tim Bausher |
| 2002-Glenn Woolard |
| 2006-Ryan Loper |
| 2010-Shayne Houck |
| 2011-Shayne Houck |
|
| Pitcher of the Year |
| 2006-Mike McCardell |
| 2009-Darin Gorski |
|
| Rookie of the Year |
| 1995-Andy Bausher |
| 1996-John Rozich |
| 2002-Paul Garber |
| 2004-Ryan Loper |
| 2006-Chad Lightcap |
| 2009-Shayne Houck |
|
| Coach of the Year |
| 1997-Matt Royer |
| 1999-Matt Royer |
| 2001-Matt Royer |
| 2002-Matt Royer |
| 2004-Chris Blum |
| 2006-Chris Blum |
| 2007-Chris Blum |
|
| All-PSAC First Team |
| 1979-Earl Weaver |
| 1981-Jerry Hand |
| 1982-Bill Sassaman |
| 1983-Bill Sassaman, Jim Emerick, Bob Graber, Bill Pugh |
| 1984-Bill Sassaman, Randy Remaly |
| 1985-Mike Tarconish |
| 1986-Fred Tomasko |
| 1987-Jim Bergeman |
| 1988-Todd Greenawalt |
| 1989-Todd Greenawalt, Lee Stewart |
| 1990-Lee Stewart, Rich Kriebel |
| 1991-Mike Neal |
| 1996-John Rozich, Matt Wright, Jim Gerner, Eric Clemmer* |
| 1997-Eric Clemmer*, Andy Bausher, Ryan Vogelsong, Kevin Bonner |
| 1998-Ryan Vogelsong, John Rozich |
| 1999-John Rozich, Dave Steckel, Steve Fitch |
| 2000-Steve Fitch, Stan Haraczka |
| 2001-Tim Bausher, Danny Nelson, Glenn Woolard, Dennis Smeding |
| 2002-Glenn Woolard, Paul Garber, Al Fitch, Dennis Smeding |
| 2003-Joe Bosack, Al Fitch, Rob McCuen |
| 2004-Paul Koropchak, John Yearsley |
| 2005-Kyle Costello, Jeff Craig, Ryan Loper |
| 2006-Ryan Loper, Mike McCardell*, Matt Maradeo |
| 2007-Mike McCardell*, Ryan Loper, Nate Kranz, Sean Bond, Jason Mills |
| 2008-Darin Gorski, Chad Lightcap |
| 2009-Adam Maini, Mike Kacelowicz, Darin Gorski |
| 2010-Shayne Houck, Jared Frey, James Quigley, Mike Dugan, Nathan Reed |
| 2011-Shayne Houck, Mike Dugan, James Quigley, Matt Albaugh |
| 2012-Shayne Houck, Cody Montz, Dominick Ruscitti |
| 2013-Matt Albaugh, Brandon Martinez |
| 2014-Kyle Stoudt, Brandon Martinez |
| 2016-Matt Swarmer |
| 2021-Collin Bishop |
| 2023-Gavin Moretski |
|
| All-PSAC Second Team |
| 1979-Scott Schlecter |
| 1981-Dom Peluso, Jim Bannon, Scott Seiz, Chris Heyer |
| 1995-Brad Harkins, Rob Ferry, Dan Weigle, Jim Gerner, Jim Kelly |
| 1996-Andy Bausher, Dan Weigle, Eric Clemmer* |
| 1997-John Rozich, Eric Clemmer*, Steve Fitch |
| 1999-Eric Clemmer, Pat Lancianese, Chris Spinozzi* |
| 2000-Chris Lauwers, Dan Newton |
| 2001-Al Fitch, Pat Lancianese, Stan Haraczka |
| 2002-Rob McCuen |
| 2004-Matt Keller, Rob McCuen |
| 2005-Paul Koropchak, Clay Kuklick, Matt Keller |
| 2006-Josh Fink, Nate Kranz, Jeff Craig |
| 2007-Chad Lightcap, Ryan Loper |
| 2008-Philip Rummel |
| 2009-James Quigley |
| 2010-Mike Kacelowicz |
| 2012-Matt Albaugh, Brad Stoudt |
| 2013-Kyle Stoudt, Brett Hauck |
| 2014-Brandon Cholish |
| 2015-Paul Piromalli |
| 2018-Gavilan Fogarty-Harnish, Nick Lafferty |
| 2021-Gavin Moretski |
| 2022-Mike Kelly |
| 2023-Ethan Martini, Jake Skrocki |
| 2024-Jimmy Kerley |
| 2025-Bo Barthol, Jared Ferguson |
|
| *selected as both position player and pitcher |
|
| Regional Honors |
|
| ABCA North Atlantic/Atlantic Coach of the Year |
| 2001-Matt Royer |
| 2002-Matt Royer |
| 2004-Chris Blum |
| 2007-Chris Blum |
| 2010-Chris Blum |
|
| ABCA Player of the Year |
| 2010-Shayne Houck |
|
| ABCA Pitcher of the Year |
| 1998-Ryan Vogelsong |
| 2002-Glenn Woolard |
| 2005-Matt Keller |
| 2007-Mike Mccardell |
|
| ABCA/Rawlings Golden Glove First Team |
| 2007-Mike McCardell |
| 2012-Shayne Houck |
|
| ABCA/Rawlings Golden Glove Second Team |
| 2012-Brett Hauck |
|
| ABCA All-Atlantic Region First Team |
| 1998-Ryan Vogelsong |
| 1999-John Rozich |
| 2001-Tim Bausher, Dennis Smeding |
| 2002-Glenn Woolard |
| 2003-Joe Bosack |
| 2005-Matt Keller, Kyle Costello |
| 2006-Ryan Loper, Matt Maradeo |
| 2007-Mike Mccardell, Sean Bond |
| 2008-Darin Gorski |
| 2010-Shayne Houck, James Quigley |
| 2011-Shayne Houck |
| 2012-Shayne Houck |
|
| ABCA All-Atlantic Region Second Team |
| 1989-Lee Stewart |
| 1999-Dave Steckel, Steve Fitch |
| 2000-Steve Fitch, Stan Haraczka |
| 2001-Glenn Woolard |
| 2002-Dennis Smeding |
| 2006-Mike McCardell |
| 2007-Nate Kranz, Chad Lightcap, Ryan Loper, Jason Mills |
| 2008-Chad Lightcap |
| 2010-Nathan Reed |
| 2012-Dominick Ruscitti |
| 2014-Kyle Stoudt, Brandon Martinez |
| 2022-Mike Kelly |
| 2023-Ethan Martini, Gavin Moretski |
|
| Daktronics Atlantic Region Pitcher of the Year |
| 2007-Jason Mills |
|
| Daktronics All-Atlantic Region First Team |
| 2007-Jason Mills, Mike McCardell |
| 2008-Darin Gorski |
| 2009-Darin Gorski |
| 2010-Shayne Houck, Nathan Reed |
| 2011-Shayne Houck, Cody Montz |
| 2012-Shayne Houck |
|
| Daktronics All-Atlantic Region Second Team |
| 2007-Sean Bond, Ryan Loper |
| 2008-Chad Lightcap |
| 2009-Mike Kacelowicz, Adam Maini |
| 2010-James Quigley |
| 2014-Kyle Stoudt, Brandon Martinez |
|
| NCBWA All-Atlantic Region First Team |
| 2005-Matt Keller, Kyle Costello |
| 2006-Ryan Loper, Mike McCardell |
| 2007-Mike McCardell |
| 2009-Darin Gorski, Mike Kacelowicz, Adam Maini |
| 2010-Shayne Houck |
| 2011-Shayne Houck |
| 2012-Shayne Houck |
|
| NCBWA All-Atlantic Region Second Team |
| 2006-Matt Maradeo |
| 2007-Jason Mills, Sean Bond, Ryan Loper |
| 2010-Nathan Reed |
| 2014-Kyle Stoudt, Brandon Martinez |
|
| NCBWA All-Atlantic Region Third Team |
| 2011-Matt Albaugh |
|
| NCBWA All-Atlantic Region Honorable Mention Team |
| 2010-Jared Frey, James Quigley, Mike Dugan |
| 2011-Mike Dugan |
| 2012-Matt Albaugh, Cody Montz, Dominick Ruscitti |
| 2013-Brandon Martinez |
|
| South Atlantic Third Team |
| 1983-Bill Sassaman |
|
| National Honors |
|
| ABCA |
|
| Div. II Player of the Year |
| 2002-Glenn Woolard |
|
| Div. II Pitcher of the Year |
| 2002-Glenn Woolard |
|
| All-America First Team |
| 2002-Glenn Woolard |
|
| All-America Second Team |
| 1998-Ryan Vogelsong |
| 2007-Mike McCardell |
|
| All-America Third Team |
| 2001-Tim Bausher |
| 2005-Matt Keller |
|
| Daktronics |
|
| Daktronics All-America Second Team |
| 2007-Jason Mills |
| 2010-Shayne Houck |
|
| Daktronics All-America Third Team |
| 2007-Mike Mccardell |
| 2009-Darin Gorski |
|
| NCBWA |
|
| NCBWA All-America First Team |
| 2010-Shayne Houck |
|
| NCBWA All-America Third Team |
| 2009-Darin Gorski |
|
| NCBWA All-America Honorable Mention Team |
| 2009-Adam Maini |
|
|
| Academic Honors |
|
| Capital One Academic All-America First Team |
| 2014-Brandon Martinez |
|
| Capital One Academic All-America Second Team |
| 2015-Brandon Martinez |
|
| CSC Academic All-District |
| 2023-Mitchell Peers, Dominic Proietto, Jake Skrocki |
| 2024-Trevor Leverington, Dominic Proietto, Jake Skrocki |
|
| CoSIDA/ESPN The Magazine Academic All-District II First Team |
| 2007-Jeff Craig |
| 2014-Brandon Martinez |
| 2015-Brandon Martinez |
|
| CoSIDA/ESPN The Magazine Academic All-District II Second Team |
| 2006-Jeff Craig |
| 2010-Jared Frey |
|
| PSAC Spring Top 10 |
| 2005-Clay Kuklick |
| 2007-Jeff Craig |
| 2014-Brandon Martinez |
